On this page
A recruiter quotes $120k salary. A client quotes $90/hour. Which is “more”? Without an all-in cost lens, you are comparing a loaded employment package to raw contractor revenue — and that mismatch is how people underprice contracts or quit a job too early.
This guide walks through the major cost layers on both sides for US readers. Pair it with the 1099 vs W-2 comparator, freelance rate calculator, and 1099 vs W-2 take-home. Educational planning only — not a classification opinion and not career advice.
In short: Compare the all-in cost of employment vs freelance: taxes, benefits, unpaid time, and utilization — so rate and salary quotes stop looking interchangeable.
What “all-in” means here
Employer all-in cost is roughly salary + employer payroll taxes + benefits + paid time off + equipment/overhead the company absorbs. Freelancer all-in cost to deliver the same capacity is roughly the rate × billable hours needed, after you personally fund taxes, benefits, unpaid admin, tools, and downtime.
Clients who “convert” salary ÷ 2,080 into an hourly contract rate usually leave those layers on the table. Freelancers who reverse the same shortcut undercharge relative to the job they left.
Layer 1 — Taxes and withholding
Employees see withholding and share FICA with the employer. Contractors typically receive gross payments and cover self-employment tax plus income tax (and often state tax) from their own cash. See self-employment tax explained and how to calculate self-employment tax.
Educational implication: a freelance gross that matches a former salary is not a take-home match. Build a cushion into rates and transfers — percentage ranges help while you refine with a pro.
Try the calculator1099 vs W-2 CompareSee how a freelance rate stacks up against a salary once taxes and overhead come out.OpenLayer 2 — Benefits you used to get “for free”
Health insurance premiums, retirement matches, dental/vision, disability, parental leave, and learning budgets are real compensation. When you freelance, list them in annual dollars as best you can. A contract that looks 20% above salary can still lose after benefits if insurance alone is expensive in your market.
You do not need perfect HR data. Rough annual ranges beat treating benefits as zero.
Layer 3 — Paid time off vs unpaid downtime
Salary usually includes holidays, vacation, and sick days inside the annual number. Contractors who only invoice delivered work must either raise rates to fund unpaid weeks or accept lower annual cash. Day-rate and hourly quotes that ignore vacation math recreate the 2,080-hour fantasy — see day rate to salary equivalent and billable hours per year.
Layer 4 — Utilization and unpaid business time
Employees are paid for meetings, slack, and internal work. Freelancers often eat sales, proposals, invoicing, collections, and tool maintenance. Available hours ≠ billable hours (billable vs available hours). All-in freelance cost to the client may look “high” hourly while your effective paid hours are far below 40/week.
A simple all-in comparison method
- Employment side: salary + rough employer burden (payroll taxes + benefits + PTO value) → annual loaded cost / true take-home after employee taxes.
- Freelance side: target take-home + self-funded benefits + tax cushion + overhead → required gross ÷ realistic billable hours → floor rate.
- Compare spendable money and risk (payment timing, pipeline, classification), not just the headline numbers.
Illustrative only: $100,000 W-2 with meaningful benefits might “feel” like $115k–$130k+ of loaded employer cost and leave mid-$70ks take-home depending on taxes and elections. A freelancer needing ~$75k take-home after a 35% cushion and self-paid insurance may need ~$115k+ gross — at 1,200 billable hours, that is ~$96/hour floor before market positioning. Small assumption changes flip the winner; that is why spreadsheets beat vibes.
For clients reading this
If you are hiring, a fair contractor rate often exceeds salary ÷ 2,080 because you are not buying idle capacity, benefits administration, or employment risk the same way. Budgeting only the old salary number is how projects stall when strong independents walk. Classification still must follow the facts — preference does not create a 1099.
For freelancers reading this
Price from take-home and capacity, then sanity-check the market. Use how much to charge, raise thoughtfully with rate raise scripts, and do not quit solely because a contract hourly “looks bigger” than salary ÷ 2,080 — see when to quit your job for freelance.
Next steps
- Run scenarios in the 1099 vs W-2 tool
- Build a floor rate with the freelance rate calculator
- Translate packages via hourly ↔ salary